THE DERMA CHECK FAVICON NEW (2)
For trustworthy, transparent, and extensive product tests
Benefits Top 5 Attention

The 5 Best and Safest Eyebrow Serums of 2024 (3 Serums Were Rated “Poor”)

Some eyebrow serums do not work, while others can cause severe side effects. Our dermatology experts present the top 5 eyebrow growth serums for thick, healthy, and expressive eyebrows.

Issue July 2024
Derma Check Prüfteam

Investigated and tested by

Dr. Rosmy Barrios 125

Medically reviewed by

In this test report:
Benefits Best Choice 2024 Attention
Results at a Glance
“Over a period of several months, we tested 28 eyebrow serums in depth, analysed pertinent scientific studies, and consulted with dermatologists.
We were particularly impressed with the eyebrow serum “Orphica BROW“, which stood out as the clear test winner with extraordinary effectiveness and scoring the top mark of “Outstanding” with 9.8 points out of 10.
Another two serums also impressed with an “Excellent” rating.
Regrettably, we had to award 3 products a rating of “Poor“.”
The Derma Check blue

Bold, full, and defined eyebrows give the face a particularly profound and expressive look. So it’s no surprise that products such as eyebrow pencils, powders, and gels have been hugely popular for many years.

Instead of relying on temporary fixes such as eyebrow pencils, however, people are now looking for a more natural way to strengthen, thicken, and shape their own eyebrows.

Especially after years of over-plucking, many are searching for a functional and sustainable solution.

Many people are turning to eyebrow serums as the answer. Renowned for providing an effective, efficient, and practical solution that nourishes natural brows from the inside out, they encourage growth and achieve the overall appearance of thicker, fuller eyebrows. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]

What Should You Really Expect From A High-Quality Eyebrow Serum?
Month 1

You might start to notice improvements in the fullness and health of your eyebrows after even a short time. However, be cautious with any promises of dramatic changes within the first month—significant improvements take time.

Month 2

Many people notice a significant thickening and strengthening of their eyebrows after using a high-quality serum for two months, which leads to a noticeably bolder look. This often reduces the need for eyebrow pencils and powders.

Month 3

Many users experience an impressive transformation of their eyebrows after three months, often described as a difference “like night and day.” For the best results, continuous use throughout this period is recommended.

Maintenance of results

To sustain the achieved results, it is usually enough to apply the serum 2-3 times a week. If you stop using the serum altogether, your eyebrows may gradually return to their original state.

Additional Tip: If you prefer less intense growth and volume, you can reduce the application frequency to 2-3 times a week from the start instead of using the serum daily. This allows you to tailor the benefits to your individual needs.

But Watch Out: Many Eyebrow Serums Don’t Work

“A top-quality eyebrow serum can work wonders,” explains Dr Rosmy Barrios, a consultant in aesthetic medicine. “It helps nourish the eyebrows, encourages growth, and therefore creates a visibly bolder appearance.”

Reality, however, often disappoints: “Many of the eyebrow serums on the market, particularly those of lower quality, do not live up to their promises,” warns Dr Barrios.

“They don’t deliver the thick, full brows you’re hoping for because they lack the necessary high-quality ingredients.”

Faced with a flood of (empty) promotional promises from the cosmetics industry, consumers find it challenging to correctly identify which eyebrow serums will truly result in visibly thicker and stronger brows.

For this reason, our proven Derma Check test team has put 28 popular eyebrow serums through extensive testing based on trials, research results, our in-house analysis, and countless product reviews.

Thanks to this in-depth approach, we can recommend the eyebrow serums we believe to be the safest, most effective, and best, as well as those whose ability to deliver clearly visible results we are convinced of.

Is Using an Eyebrow Serum Worth Your While?

There are many individual needs and uses that make an eyebrow serum an attractive option. Here are some examples where an eyebrow serum can be particularly beneficial:

Promoting Growth: Stimulates and activates natural eyebrow growth for a fuller look.
Dense and Defined Brows: Ideal for those wanting fuller, more defined eyebrows.
Strengthening Thin Brows: Helpful for thin or sparse eyebrows that need strengthening.
Natural Appearance: Provides a low-maintenance, natural look without daily makeup.
Makeup Alternative: Perfect for those seeking a natural alternative to eyebrow pencils, powders, or gels.
Protection from Cosmetic Damage: Supports regeneration and strengthening of eyebrows after frequent use of makeup removers or harsh cosmetics.
Hair Restoration: Useful for restoring eyebrows after loss due to illness or medical treatments (medical consultation recommended).
Repair Over-Plucked Brows: Helps reliably regenerate eyebrows damaged by over-plucking.
How Can You Find the Best and Most Suitable Eyebrow Serum?

We have analysed numerous serums in detail and determined the most important criteria for a high-quality eyebrow serum.

Most users seek visible thickening and strengthening of their eyebrows. Therefore, we based our testing criteria on eyebrow serums with proven ingredients that best meet this need.

Consequently, we considered the following six criteria to be of particular importance in our test:

Ingredients with a growth-promoting effect: The serum should incorporate a prostaglandin analogue along with effective ingredients like peptides, vitamins, and plant extracts.
Fast and efficient results: A good eyebrow serum delivers demonstrable results in the form of thicker, stronger eyebrows within 2 to 4 weeks.
Good tolerance: The serum should be gentle on the skin, ideally dermatologically tested to minimize the risk of irritation and allergies.
Ease of use: An easy and precise application with an applicator that allows targeted and economical dosing is essential.
Positive reviews: Testimonials and reviews from other users provide insight into the serum’s effectiveness and tolerance.
Value for money: Effective eyebrow serums typically cost between £40 and £80. Products significantly cheaper should be viewed with skepticism, while those priced beyond £80 are often paying mainly for product marketing.
Expert Advice
“We would strongly suggest using one of the eyebrow serums from the following list of top products.
Based on our tests, these products lead the field in their category. Additionally, you minimize the risk of making a poor choice, as many eyebrow serums on the market contain questionable ingredients and dubious formulas.
In our experience, you can expect to see significant improvements and visible results within just 2-4 weeks with the following eyebrow serums.”
The Derma Check blue

The 5 Best and Safest Eyebrow Serums in our 2024 Test

TEST WINNER
Derma
Check
Outstanding
(9.8/10)
Tested:
28 Eyebrow Serums
Issue: 08/2024
DermaCheck.
Orphica BROW
TEST WINNER
Derma
Check
Outstanding
(9.8/10)
Tested:
28 Eyebrow Serums
Issue: 08/2024
DermaCheck.
OUR QUALITY RATING
9,8/10 – Outstanding
“Orphica BROW impresses with its excellent quality, safety, and effectiveness. In our tests, it consistently received positive reviews. It is our clear favorite and the top choice for 2024.”
Orphica BROW
Ingredients & Safety: 9.8/10
(0 = worrying) (10 = very safe)
Eyebrow Growth: 9.7/10
(0 = weak) (10 = very strong)
Eyebrow Density: 9.8/10
(0 = Not dense) (10 = very dense)
Customer Feedback: 9.9/10
(0 = Poor) (10 = Excellent)
Value for Money: 10/10
(0 = Poor) (10 = Excellent)
Buy Product Securely
Test Winner 2024
PROS:
Orphica BROW achieved the best results in the test.
Fastest results, mostly after only 2 weeks.
Eyebrows grow significantly thicker and more defined.
Eyebrows grow more resilient, more voluminous, and formable.
Innovative and potent active ingredients.
Brush allows for precise and smudge-free application.
Orphica BROW has scored top results in the trade press and in tests for years.
Part of “Orphica,” a reputable and internationally active brand with headquarters in France.
Did not trigger any irritation, redness, or other side effects in the test.
CONS:
Out of stock frequently.
Watch out for fakes – you can only get guaranteed authentic products from an authorised retailer.

Orphica BROW Eyebrow Serum Review

The “Orphica BROW” eyebrow serum from Orphica fulfilled all the criteria required of a first-class and effective eyebrow serum in our test most impressively.

As a result, it is the winner of our test and, according to our results, currently the leading eyebrow serum in Europe.

What Kind of People is This Eyebrow Serum Particularly Suitable for?

We would recommend this serum especially to anyone who would like to visibly thicken, strengthen, and fortify their natural eyebrows and simultaneously minimize the risk of potential side effects associated with prostaglandin analogue-based brow serums.

The Orphica BROW serum has been established and proven on the market for years thanks to its proven and dermatologically tested formulation of active ingredients.

How Effective and Safe is Orphica BROW?

The active ingredient in Orphica BROW is a prostaglandin analogue which, when combined with the other components in the formula, has an excellent, swift, and verifiable effect.

There are very few reports of side effects. This is an indication of the high tolerability and safety of the ingredients used.

During our test, we found that the applicator made it possible to apply a precise and uniform dose. The serum features a pleasant consistency that helps prevent smudging or unintentional eye contact. This is important to prevent irritation and discomfort.

How Happy Are the Users?

Both the results of our in-house testing and the reviews of external consumers show a consistently high level of satisfaction with the effectiveness of the eyebrow serum.

The users emphasized especially how quickly and noticeably effective the serum is, as well as its outstanding tolerability.

Below you can see the results of one of our test participants:

Augenbrauen Wimpern Vorher2Augenbrauen Wimpern Nachher2
Note: You can move the slider to the right or left to see the differences. The pictured user applied the “Orphica BROW” eyebrow serum regularly and is not wearing any make-up in either photo. Additionally, the “Orphica REALASH” lash serum was used to enhance her lashes. She claims her eyebrows were previously over-plucked, and there is a noticeable difference in both the eyebrows and eyelashes.

How About the Value for Money?

When compared directly with other premium eyebrow serums also based on prostaglandin analogues (PGA), the “Orphica BROW” serum stands out due to its excellent value for money.

The price positions it below many competitor products without any compromise on quality and effectiveness.

Considering the high-quality, effective formula and the excellent reputation of the Orphica brand, we feel that the price of the serum is entirely reasonable.

Which Are the Active Ingredients?

The Orphica BROW eyebrow serum contains several ingredients. Let’s break down which ingredients could stimulate growth, whether a PGA is involved, and whether there are any other worrying ingredients.

Prostaglandin analogue: Yes, “Dechloro Dihydroxy Difluoro Ethylcloprostenolamide” is used.

Other ingredients that could encourage eyebrow growth: Biotinoyl Tripeptide-1, Panthenol, Panax Ginseng Root Extract, Urtica dioica (Nettle) Extract, Niacinamide, Soluble Collagen.

Questionable ingredients: The prostaglandin analogue used may cause side effects. All other ingredients are considered harmless.

Our Conclusion

If you want visibly thicker, more defined, and stronger eyebrows, the “Orphica BROW” eyebrow serum is the right choice for you.

Combining a high level of effectiveness with impeccable quality at a moderate price, it not only offers outstanding value for money but also contributes to a compelling overall score of 9.8/10 in the Derma Check.

This means that “Orphica BROW” is our eyebrow serum test winner and our clear recommendation for 2024.

M2BEAUTE EYEBROW RENEWING SERUM
6.271 Reviews
OUR QUALITY RATING
9,1/10 – Excellent
M2BEAUTE EYEBROW RENEWING SERUM
Ingredients & Safety: 8.9/10
(0 = worrying) (10 = very safe)
Eyebrow Growth: 9.5/10
(0 = weak) (10 = very strong)
Eyebrow Density: 9.6/10
(0 = Not dense) (10 = very dense)
Customer Feedback: 9.2/10
(0 = Poor) (10 = Excellent)
Value for Money: 8.1/10
(0 = Poor) (10 = Excellent)
PROS:
M2 Beauté Eyebrow Renewing Serum achieved very good results in our test.
Quick results, often visible within 3 weeks.
Eyebrows become noticeably thicker and more nourished.
Effectively stimulates growth.
Contains innovative active ingredients promising high effectiveness.
Precise and easy application thanks to a good applicator.
Proven formula over many years.
M2 BEAUTÉ is a well-known and reputable brand in the cosmetics industry.
CONS:
Potentially stronger side effects for sensitive skin.
Very high price compared to the test winner.

M2 Beauté Eyebrow Renewing Serum Review

The “M2 Beauté Eyebrow Renewing Serum” showed impressive results in our test, meeting many criteria for a top-notch eyebrow serum. It closely follows our test winner, securing second place among currently available eyebrow serums.

Who is this Eyebrow Serum Particularly Suitable for?

We recommend this serum for those seeking intensive and effective care for their eyebrows. However, people with sensitive skin should be cautious due to the inclusion of Norbimatoprost and Black Sea Rod Oil, both potent ingredients.

How Effective and Safe is M2 Beauté Eyebrow Renewing Serum?

The M2 Beauté Serum combines Norbimatoprost and Black Sea Rod Oil, known for their effectiveness but also carrying a higher risk of side effects. While the formula has proven effective over the years, our test noted some reports of irritation and side effects. The serum comes with a convenient applicator for precise and even application, and its pleasant consistency prevents smudging or eye irritation.

How Happy Are the Users?

Internal tests and external consumer reviews show high satisfaction with the serum’s effectiveness. Users report quick and noticeable improvements, emphasizing the serum’s significant efficacy and relatively good tolerability despite occasional side effects.

How About the Value for Money?

Compared to other premium eyebrow serums, the M2 Beauté Serum is notably more expensive. While it delivers excellent results and reliable performance, we question whether this justifies its high price.

Which Are the Active Ingredients?

The M2 Beauté Eyebrow Renewing Serum includes several growth-promoting ingredients:

Prostaglandin analogue: Yes, Norbimatoprost is used, along with Black Sea Rod Oil, another prostaglandin derivative.

Other growth-promoting ingredients: Panthenol, Biotin, Sodium PCA, Sodium Hyaluronate, Hyaluronic Acid, various Amino Acids.

Questionable ingredients: Norbimatoprost and Black Sea Rod Oil are potent and may cause side effects. Other ingredients are considered harmless.

Our Conclusion

The “M2 Beauté Eyebrow Renewing Serum” is an excellent choice for those wanting dense and strong eyebrows and willing to pay a higher price. Its high effectiveness and solid quality justify the price in most cases. Coupled with M2 BEAUTÉ’s long-standing brand quality, it earns a commendable overall score of 9.1/10 in the Derma Check. Thus, the “M2 Beauté Eyebrow Renewing Serum” is our runner-up and a strong recommendation for 2024, especially when the test winner, Orphica BROW, is out of stock.

REVITABROW
3rd Place:
RevitaBrow
5.444 Reviews
OUR QUALITY RATING
8,9/10 – Excellent
REVITABROW
Ingredients & Safety: 9.5/10
(0 = worrying) (10 = very safe)
Eyebrow Growth: 9.4/10
(0 = weak) (10 = very strong)
Eyebrow Density: 9.4/10
(0 = Not dense) (10 = very dense)
Customer Feedback: 8.8/10
(0 = Poor) (10 = Excellent)
Value for Money: 7.4/10
(0 = Poor) (10 = Excellent)
PROS:
RevitaBrow demonstrated very high effectiveness in our test.
Visible results are often noticeable after 3-4 weeks.
Eyebrows appear thicker and more nourished.
Contains an effective combination of growth-promoting ingredients.
Easy-to-use applicator for precise application.
Trusted and proven formula over many years.
RevitaLash Cosmetics is a well-known, reputable brand.
CONS:
Very high price, the most expensive serum in our test.
Does not offer better effectiveness despite the high price.

RevitaBrow Eyebrow Serum Review

The “RevitaBrow” eyebrow serum delivered excellent results in our test, meeting many criteria for a top-notch eyebrow serum.

It ranks third in our eyebrow serum comparison, standing out with a formula similar to our test winner.

Who is this Eyebrow Serum Particularly Suitable for?

We recommend RevitaBrow for those seeking a highly effective solution for thicker, stronger eyebrows and are willing to pay a premium price.

The manufacturer was one of the first to market such a serum, which is reflected in its price. There are cheaper alternatives with similar efficacy, but “RevitaBrow” is a reliable and long-established product.

How Effective and Safe is RevitaBrow?

RevitaBrow uses a formula similar to the test winner Orphica BROW, including the prostaglandin analogue “Dechloro Dihydroxy Difluoro Ethylcloprostenolamide.”

This formula is highly effective when combined with other quality ingredients. Our test found very few reports of side effects, indicating good tolerability.

The applicator allows precise application of the serum, and its pleasant consistency prevents smudging or entering the eyes, avoiding irritation.

User Satisfaction

Both our internal testing and external consumer reviews show consistently high satisfaction with the effectiveness and quality of RevitaBrow. Users report rapid and noticeable results and good tolerability.

Value for Money

Compared to other premium eyebrow serums, RevitaBrow is the most expensive product in our test. However, it offers excellent results and high reliability.

The outstanding quality and effective ingredient combination justify the price to some extent, but it may not be accessible for budget-conscious consumers.

Which Ingredients Are Included?

RevitaBrow eyebrow serum contains a variety of ingredients that can promote growth:

Prostaglandin analogue: Yes, “Dechloro Dihydroxy Difluoro Ethylcloprostenolamide” is used.

Other growth-promoting ingredients: Biotin, Panax Ginseng Extract, Camellia Oleifera Extract, Swertia Japonica Extract, Biotinoyl Tripeptide-1, Octapeptide-2.

Questionable ingredients: The prostaglandin analogue used may cause side effects. All other ingredients are considered harmless.

Our Conclusion

RevitaBrow is an excellent choice for those willing to invest in the care and growth of their eyebrows. It offers very high effectiveness and excellent quality, but comes with a high price tag.

With a compelling overall score of 8.9/10, it secures third place in the Derma Check.

UKBROW
2.091 Reviews
OUR QUALITY RATING
8,7/10 – Very Good
UKBROW
Ingredients & Safety: 8.6/10
(0 = worrying) (10 = very safe)
Eyebrow Growth: 8.7/10
(0 = weak) (10 = very strong)
Eyebrow Density: 9.1/10
(0 = Not dense) (10 = very dense)
Customer Feedback: 8.7/10
(0 = Poor) (10 = Excellent)
Value for Money: 8.5/10
(0 = Poor) (10 = Excellent)
PROS:
ukbrow Eyebrow Serum shows effective growth and density of eyebrows.
Visible results quickly, often within 3-6 weeks.
Uses an effective PGA ingredient that promotes growth and density.
Includes many natural extracts like Green Tea and Centella Asiatica that have soothing effects.
Well-combined formula with moisturizing ingredients like Glycerin and Butylene Glycol.
CONS:
The prostaglandin analogue used may cause side effects more frequently than the one in the test winner.
Packaging looks rather cheap in comparison.
Priced similarly to the test winner, but less impressive overall.

ukbrow Eyebrow Serum Review

The “ukbrow Eyebrow Serum” from uklash secured fourth place in our test. It proved to be a very effective serum but fell short in some aspects compared to our top contenders.

Who is This Eyebrow Serum Particularly Suitable for?

This serum is especially suitable for those who may have had less than satisfactory experiences with other prostaglandin analogue products. Its special formula offers an effective alternative that can deliver visible and convincing results in eyebrow growth.

How Effective and Safe is ukbrow Eyebrow Serum?

The ukbrow Eyebrow Serum contains the prostaglandin analogue “Isopropyl Cloprostenate,” which contributes to effective growth. This ingredient is supported by other growth-promoting components like Myristoyl Pentapeptide-17 and Biotinoyl Tripeptide-1.

During our tests, the serum showed good tolerability, though mild side effects were reported more frequently. Other Derma Check tests have shown that the PGA used here can cause more side effects than the one used by the test winner.

The applicator allowed for precise application, but the packaging left a rather cheap impression, which does not match the premium price.

How Happy Are the Users?

Our internal tests and feedback from external users confirm a high level of satisfaction with the effectiveness of the ukbrow Eyebrow Serum. Most users reported noticeable thickening and improvement in eyebrow structure within 3-6 weeks. The results were largely positive, though slight irritations occurred in some cases.

How About the Value for Money?

Compared to other premium eyebrow serums, the ukbrow Eyebrow Serum is priced similarly to our test winner. However, the packaging was somewhat disappointing. This slightly impacts the overall impression, though the quality and effectiveness of the ingredients remain solid.

Which Are the Active Ingredients?

The ukbrow Eyebrow Serum consists of a carefully selected combination of growth-promoting and nourishing ingredients. Here are the key components:

Prostaglandin analogue: Yes, “Isopropyl Cloprostenate”

Other growth-promoting ingredients: Biotinoyl Tripeptide-1, Myristoyl Pentapeptide-17, Panthenol, Camellia Sinensis Leaf Extract, Centella Asiatica Extract

Questionable ingredients: The prostaglandin analogue used can cause side effects such as irritation in some users. All other ingredients are considered harmless.

Our Conclusion

The “ukbrow Eyebrow Serum” is a good alternative for those looking for an effective eyebrow serum and who have been less satisfied with other products. It shows effective results in growth and density but has slight drawbacks regarding packaging quality and potential side effects.

Overall, the ukbrow Eyebrow Serum achieves a commendable overall rating of 8.7/10 in the Derma Check magazine, making it a recommended, though not leading, choice.

OLAPLEX BROWBOND
469 Reviews
OUR QUALITY RATING
7,7/10 – Good
OLAPLEX BROWBOND
Ingredients & Safety: 9.4/10
(0 = worrying) (10 = very safe)
Eyebrow Growth: 6.7/10
(0 = weak) (10 = very strong)
Eyebrow Density: 6.9/10
(0 = Not dense) (10 = very dense)
Customer Feedback: 8.1/10
(0 = Poor) (10 = Excellent)
Value for Money: 7.3/10
(0 = Poor) (10 = Excellent)
PROS:
Browbond Building Serum shows solid results in terms of care and conditioning.
Only eyebrow serum in the top 5 list that does not use PGA.
Positive impact on the overall health of the eyebrows.
The applicator allows for easy application.
Olaplex invests in high-quality, well-tolerated ingredients.
Very good brand reputation.
Very low risk of side effects.
CONS:
No prostaglandin analogue, so less effective for eyebrow growth.
More expensive compared to some competing products.
Promised growth effects often fall short of expectations.

Olaplex Browbond Building Serum Review

The “Browbond Building Serum” from Olaplex impressed us in terms of care and conditioning, though it has notable weaknesses in eyebrow growth. It earned fifth place and our “Good” rating.

Who is This Eyebrow Serum Particularly Suitable For?

We recommend this serum for those focusing on the health and care of their eyebrows rather than intense growth. The ingredients ensure a healthier and more nourished appearance for care-conscious users.

How Effective and Safe is Browbond Building Serum?

The “Browbond Building Serum” is highly tolerable as it does not use a prostaglandin analogue. Ingredients like Palmitoyl Pentapeptide-83 Amide and Biotin are known to strengthen eyebrow structure and make them more resilient. The applicator ensures easy application without dosing errors.

How Happy Are the Users?

Feedback from our internal tests and external reviews shows general satisfaction with the serum’s conditioning properties. However, the lesser effectiveness in eyebrow growth is often noted. Users prioritizing overall eyebrow health respond positively to the product.

How About the Value for Money?

The “Browbond Building Serum” is priced higher than some competitors, including our test winner, Orphica BROW. Given its solid care properties and well-tolerated formula, we consider the value for money to be good, although there are cheaper alternatives with potentially higher growth rates.

Which Are the Active Ingredients?

The “Browbond Building Serum” from Olaplex contains several conditioning ingredients. Let’s examine the ingredients and their potential impact on eyebrow growth and safety:

Prostaglandin analogue: No, none used.

Other ingredients that could encourage eyebrow growth: Palmitoyl Pentapeptide-83 Amide, Acetyl Tetrapeptide-3, Myristoyl Pentapeptide-17, Palmitoyl Tetrapeptide-20 Amide, Biotin, Panthenol, Avena Sativa (Oat) Kernel Extract, Trifolium Pratense (Clover) Flower Extract.

Questionable ingredients: None found; the serum is considered very safe.

Our Conclusion

The “Browbond Building Serum” from Olaplex is an excellent choice for users primarily interested in improving the health and care of their eyebrows. With a respectable overall rating of 7.7/10 in our Derma Check, it secures fifth place and remains a solid option on our 2024 recommendation list.

For users who are less focused on growth, this serum offers a compelling care formula.

The Top 5 Eyebrow Growth Serums 2024 Side-by-Side

Poor: Watch Out for These 3 Eyebrow Serums!

In our eyebrow serum test, three products stood out in a particularly negative way, leading us to rate them as “Poor.” These are the eyebrow serums from “CHIMOO,” “WEWELL,” and “MELARQT.”

Achtung vor diesen mangelhaften Wimpernseren Compressed
The eyelash and eyebrow serums from “WUIIL,” “WEWELL,” and “CHIMOO” performed poorly in our tests, earning a rating of “Poor.”

There are numerous and serious reasons for this poor rating.

Inadequate Declaration of Ingredients

A significant issue was the incomplete declaration of ingredients. Consumers need to know exactly what they’re applying, especially near the eyes. Unfortunately, this clarity was missing in these eyebrow serums.

Suspected Fake Reviews and Voucher Practices

Our investigation revealed signs that these brands might be buying fake reviews. Additionally, vouchers were offered for positive reviews, which undermines their credibility.

Non-Transparent Sales and Manufacturing Practices

The sales practices of these brands appeared questionable. Lack of transparency regarding manufacturing locations and obscure production processes raises serious concerns about the reliability of these products.

Issues with Ingredient Listing

Another issue was the double listing of certain ingredients on the packaging, suggesting negligent production practices or poor quality control, which questions the accuracy and trustworthiness of the product information.

WeWell Wimpernserum weist zwei Mal den selben Inhaltsstoff aus
The “WEWELL” eyelash and eyebrow serum lists the same ingredient twice.

We Advise Caution

Due to these significant deficiencies and uncertainties, we strongly advise caution when purchasing these specific eyebrow serums. Consumers should thoroughly research and choose products that transparently and honestly disclose their ingredients and manufacturing processes.

The apparent flaws and potential dangers of these eyebrow serums highlight the importance of a careful and critical approach when selecting such a product. This ensures both safety and the desired effectiveness of the eyebrow serum.

We Tested These 28 Eyebrow Serums

Wimpernseren die wir getestet haben
We tested 28 different eyebrow serums.

Eyebrow Serums Containing PGA:

  • Orphica BROW Eyebrow Serum (Top Pick) (PGA: Dechloro Dihydroxy Difluoro Ethylcloprostenolamide)
  • M2 Beaute Eyebrow Renewing Serum (PGA: Norbimatoprost)
  • RevitaBrow Eyebrow Serum (PGA: Dechloro Dihydroxy Difluoro Ethylcloprostenolamide)
  • UKBrow Eyebrow Serum (PGA: Isopropyl Cloprostenate)
  • BrowCocaine Eyebrow Serum (PGA: Ethyl Tafluprostamide)
  • Nanobrow Eyebrow Serum (PGA: Ethyl Tafluprostamide)
  • Trucosmetics Eyebrow Serum (PGA: Isopropyl Cloprostenate)
  • RapidBrow Eyebrow Serum (PGA: Isopropyl Cloprostenate) (Uncertain ingredient listing)
  • XBrow Eyebrow Serum (PGA: Dechloro Dihydroxy Difluoro Ethylcloprostenolamide)
  • Glowfilter Better Brows Eyebrow Serum (PGA: Ethyl Tafluprostamide)

Eyebrow Serums Without PGA:

  • Olaplex Browbond Eyebrow Serum
  • KU2 Cosmetics Eyebrow Serum
  • ForChics ForBrow Eyebrow Serum
  • Eleverbrow Eyebrow Serum (Uncertain ingredient listing; eyelash serum contains PGA)
  • Luxe Eyebrow Serum
  • Rosebrow Eyebrow Serum
  • The Ordinary Lash & Brow Multi-peptides Eyebrow Serum
  • Medipharma Eyebrow Booster
  • Mahobrow Eyebrow Serum
  • Natucain Brow Eyebrow Serum
  • Brow Genius Anastasia Beverly Hills Eyebrow Serum
  • Typology L37 Serum for Lashes & Eyebrows
  • SESDERMA Lash & Brow Eyebrow Serum
  • Chimoo Lash & Eyebrow Serum
  • Zynxel Lash & Eyebrow Serum
  • MELARQT Lash & Eyebrow Serum
  • WEWELL Lash & Eyebrow Serum
  • DORZU Lash & Eyebrow Serum

How Do Eyebrow Serums Work?

Not every eyebrow serum will give you fuller and thicker brows. Many products only provide conditioning benefits without actually stimulating growth.

Our thorough analysis has shown that serums containing prostaglandin analogues significantly promote eyebrow growth. In contrast, serums without this ingredient generally do not show noticeable improvements in hair growth.

We classify eyebrow serums into two categories:

Category A: Growth-Promoting Eyebrow Serums

Growth-promoting eyebrow serums typically contain prostaglandin analogues. These ingredients extend the growth phase (anagen phase) of eyebrow hair follicles, positively influencing their life cycle.

With and Without Lash Serum Comparison Illustration English

Thanks to the prolonged growth phase, the number of eyebrow hairs present at any given time increases. This results in not only longer but significantly denser brows.

Prostaglandin analogues can also stimulate melanin production, making the hair appear darker and stronger.

However, eyebrow serums with PGA can cause side effects, such as itchy, burning, and watery eyes, skin irritation on the eyelid, or even slight skin discolouration.

To minimise these risks, choose an eyebrow serum with high-quality ingredients, a proven formulation, and a reputable brand. This ensures your safety and desired results.

Category B: Conditioning Eyebrow Serums

Conditioning eyebrow serums usually don’t have any growth-promoting effects since they lack prostaglandin analogues. Any visible increase in eyebrow thickness is generally minimal.

These serums often combine conditioning ingredients with various peptides. These peptides signal the body to repair a protein, which can theoretically lead to slight hair growth.

However, peptides vary widely in their effects, and not all promote growth. There is also a lack of substantial studies and research.

Peptide-based eyebrow serums are generally well tolerated, but side effects like irritation, redness, scaling, or itching can still occur.

This is how we Tested and Evaluated the Eyebrow Serums

So haben wir Wimpernseren getestet
Every eyebrow serum has been meticulously reviewed and tested by us.

Every eyebrow serum has been meticulously reviewed and tested by us. Our objective was to identify and evaluate the best and safest eyebrow serums on the market. To achieve this, we developed a comprehensive testing process that considers various aspects of the products.

How we Chose the Eyebrow Serums to Test

We initially focused on selecting the most popular eyebrow serums. Our research included products popular on various online platforms, recommended in beauty magazines, bestsellers on retail sites, as well as established serums and promising newcomers. This diversity ensured that we covered a wide range of products.

Independent Purchase of the Selected Eyebrow Serums

After the selection process, we independently purchased all the products, refusing any free samples to maintain impartiality in our evaluations.

Testing of the Eyebrow Serums

Once purchased, each serum underwent thorough examination. A key focus was analyzing the ingredients. We aimed to understand exactly which components were present and how they influenced eyebrow growth and density.

Evaluation of Eyebrow Serums Containing PGA

We paid special attention to eyebrow serums containing prostaglandin analogues (PGAs). These ingredients are often considered the most effective for eyebrow growth but can also have side effects. We did not automatically rate these products lower but provided guidance for informed decision-making.

Application and Design

Pinseldesign und Anwendbarkeit der Wimpernseren
We compared and tested the different brushes, their ability to take up the serum and their ease of application.

We compared the brushes, their serum uptake, and application ease. Additionally, we tested practical aspects: ease of application, potential dripping, and any unpleasant odors. We also checked if products were securely sealed before first use.

Declaration and Transparency

Another critical aspect was ingredient transparency. We verified if manufacturers provided clear and complete ingredient information.

Evaluation of Results

Application results were central to our evaluation. While we tested many serums ourselves, we also incorporated external reviews, test reports, and user feedback for a comprehensive effectiveness analysis.

Analysis of Potential Side Effects

We examined potential side effects based on ingredient analysis and user feedback to understand product risks.

Long-Term Performance

For similar ingredients, we preferred products with a proven long-term market presence, indicating reliability and safety.

Manufacturer Reputation

The reputation of the manufacturer was also a crucial factor. We looked into any dubious sales practices and how straightforward the warranty process was.

Value for Money

Finally, we assessed the price-performance ratio based on all the previous parameters. This allowed us to comprehensively evaluate the products.

The Results

Through this detailed process, we were able to make an informed evaluation of the various eyebrow serums. Our goal was to provide transparent and useful information so that you can make the best decision for your needs.

Summary of the Top 5 Eyebrow Serums:

  1. For the best results in the shortest time:
    BROW from Orphica (Rated 9.8/10, Outstanding)
    //
  2. For strong results at a high price:
    M2BEAUTÉ Eyebrow Renewing Serum (Rated 9.1/10, Excellent)
    //
  3. When price is no object and the test winner is unavailable:
    RevitaBrow from RevitaLash Cosmetics (Rated 8.9/10, Excellent)
    //
  4. If you want to try a different PGA than the test winner:
    UKBROW from UKLASH (Rated 8.7/10, Very Good)
    //
  5. If the eyebrow serum should be free of PGA:
    Browbond by Olaplex (Rated 7.7/10, Good)
The Derma Check blue

How to Properly Use Eyebrow Serums

  • Preparation: Ensure your eyebrows are thoroughly cleaned, free from makeup and oils, before applying the serum.
  • Using Eye Creams: If you use eye creams, let them absorb fully before applying the serum to avoid interfering with its absorption.
  • Applying the Serum: Apply the serum gently to your eyebrows using the applicator, distributing it evenly. Allow it to dry completely. Avoid applying it right before bed or makeup application to prevent smudging.
  • Frequency: Follow the manufacturer’s instructions. For serums with prostaglandin analogues, once daily application is usually sufficient. To maintain results, reduce to 2-3 times per week.
  • Expiry and Applicator Quality: Check the serum’s expiry date, typically 3-6 months after opening. A quality applicator ensures precise dosing without frequent dipping or dripping.
  • No Rinsing: The serum doesn’t need to be washed off and should remain on the skin to work effectively.
  • No Sharing: Avoid sharing the serum to prevent bacterial transfer.
  • Pausing Use: You can stop using the serum at any time. Your eyebrows will revert to their natural growth cycle and density.
  • Side Effects: Discontinue use if you experience side effects beyond normal skin dryness and consult a doctor for severe reactions.

By following these guidelines, you can maximize the effectiveness and safety of your eyebrow serum for fuller, denser brows.

Are Eyebrow Serums Dangerous?

Eyebrow serums have a mixed reputation in the beauty industry. One key reason is the inclusion of prostaglandin analogues (PGAs) in many of these products. Although PGAs are highly effective for hair growth, they can cause side effects in some users.

Correct Use for Maximum Safety

To minimize the risk of side effects, proper use of the serum is crucial. Consider the following points:

Product selection: Choose a serum from reputable manufacturers with positive reviews and recommendations.

Frequency of use: Adhere strictly to the recommended frequency of application. Overuse can increase the risk of side effects.

Avoid eye contact: Ensure the serum does not get into your eyes, as this can cause irritation and other side effects.

Allergy testing: Test the serum on a small patch of skin, such as the forearm, before applying it to your eyebrows to check for any allergic reactions.

Position of the European Commission

The European Commission has evaluated cosmetic products containing PGAs. As of this article’s publication, no specific actions have been taken. Therefore, eyebrow and eyelash serums with PGAs remain freely available in most countries. This underscores the importance of personal responsibility and careful use by consumers.

Conclusion

In conclusion, eyebrow serums are generally safe when used correctly and according to the guidelines mentioned above. However, it’s essential to recognize that individuals may react differently to cosmetic products. Therefore, users should exercise caution during the initial application and closely monitor their body’s response.

Dr. Rosmy Barrios 125
This article has been reviewed by Dr Rosmy Barrios. It helps us to publish correct, complete, and factual content that is in line with the latest scientific research. Dr Rosmy Barrios is a renowned specialist in Aesthetic Medicine and has a wealth of international experience. She has no influence on the selection of products, the testing methods, or the rankings. Here you can find out more about our editorial guidelines.
The Derma Check Profile Image
The test team at The Derma Check researches all products extensively, specifying the key quality features and analysing relevant research. We purchase the products we test ourselves and put them through intensive trials with our editorial team and volunteer testers. You can learn more about our testing process here.

Was the article helpful?

Our #1 recommendation for brow serums

BROW Serum

from Orphica

Shop now
Produktbild